Thursday, February 28, 2013

Small Town USA embodies big time fracking issues in NY Governments face challenges over free speech, land rights


The Town of Sanford, N.Y., population 2,400, sits in the Delaware River watershed in the foothills of the western Catskill region. If you want to get a close up look at the moral and legal complexity of the shale gas debate, Sanford and neighboring towns and villages to the west are a good place to start. The issues pitting neighbor against neighbor here extend beyond economics and environmentalism to broad ideological interpretations of freedom.

Conflict over what can be said or can’t be said at a town board meeting, and whether the state is interfering with landowners’ rights to extract assets from their properties embody monumental questions about Constitutional rights surfacing with the shale gas story. With New York’s moratorium on shale gas development pending an environmental review in its fifth year, these interwoven conflicts are heading to court for disentanglement.

The tension between rights to exploit resources versus rights to be protected against exploitation is a familiar theme in the extraction industry, and I will get to the latest develop on that in a minute. A fight over citizens’ rights to talk about these issues at a town meeting, on the other hand, is a unique wrinkle in the shale gas debate, at least in the town of Sanford, which is on the front line of the controversy.



As recounted in Under the Surface, Sanford is the place where Town Supervisor Dewey Decker organized landowners to form a group to collectively negotiate terms to lease land during the height of the shale gas boom in 2008. The coalition of several hundred landowners agreed to a deal with XTO Energy (now part of Exxon Mobile) to lease 50,000 acres for $110 million (plus 13.5 percent royalties). The terms made many farmers, including Decker, millionaires before a well was drilled. It also served as a wake up call to the rest of the state about the stakes being put into play with shale gas development.

Since then, Sanford has been in the middle of the controversy, owing partly to its position on the edge of the New York City watershed and partly due to the money on the table that reflects the value of natural gas deposits in both the Utica and Marcellus shales underlying the region. Activists from both local and regional anti-fracking groups have made the Town of Sanford and the broader Catskill region a strategic part of their efforts to ban high volume hydraulic fracturing and, consequently, shale gas development.

In September, members of the Sanford Town Board, apparently fed up with the fracking debate, passed a resolution banning further discussion of the matter during the public comment period at town meetings. Town officials with significant financial stakes in shale gas development, meanwhile, have not been silent. Acting in the capacity of Town Supervisor (rather than landowner), Decker sent a letter to Gov. Andrew Cuomo three days before the town ban urging the state to expedite the pending health and environmental review of shale gas development, and complaining that a delay was “only empowering opponents.” Prior to that, the board passed a resolution urging the state to move forward, and rejecting calls for the town to ban fracking.

The board surely has a right to take a position, but it has put itself in a vulnerable spot with its ban on speech at town meetings. True, open meetings law allow towns certain “reasonable restrictions” to manage public comment periods. But from a journalist’s view, it will set a frightening precedent if elected officials are allowed to single out certain topics for censor, especially if those topics deal with matters of overwhelming public interest, such as shale gas development. Moreover, it’s an egregious act of bad faith when the censor targets citizens following accepted protocol in an open forum designed for their input.

Not surprisingly, the Town of Sanford speech ban is being challenged. The Natural Resources Defense Council and Catskill Citizens for Safe Energy filed a suit earlier this month asking the U.S. Court of the Northern District of New York to rule that the resolution banning fracking speech at Sanford Town meetings is a constitutional infringement because it “unlawfully bars plaintiffs’ members from speaking at Town Board meetings about a matter of substantial public interest that has generated significant political activity.” The town has until March 14 to respond to the complaint. The timing from there depends on the town's response and court's schedule, said Kate Sinding, an attorney for the NRDC.

The lawsuit against the Town of Sanford is one of many that will be playing out as various stakeholders chart new legal ground related to shale gas development. On the other side of the fence, lawyers are working on a suit on behalf of landowners, like Dewey Decker, who claim government is taking away their rights to develop natural gas under their land. As reported by Gannett’s Jon Campbell today, Dan Fitzsimmons, president of the Joint Landowners Coalition of New York, said the group is looking for four people to serve as plaintiffs in a lawsuit against the Department of Environmental Conservation. The action will argue that the state’s hold on shale gas permitting, pending the outcome of a health review with no timeline, amounts to an illegal “taking” of property rights. “The lawsuit against the state will focus on claims where the failure to grant (high-volume hydrofracking) permits has deprived landowners of all economically viable uses of their real property or interfered with reasonable investment-backed expectations,” Fitzsimmons wrote to members.

The group is represented by Binghamton attorney Scott Kurkoski, who told Campbell “we’re now recognizing that the state has no intention of ever completing the SGEIS.” Kurkoski was referring to the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement, the document that includes both the health and environmental reviews necessary to proceed. (DEC Commissioner said the review will be completed within weeks, although he would not say when or whether the state will begin issuing permits.) Kurkoski’s clients collectively own sizable parts of New York’s southern Tier that cover lucrative swaths of both the Marcellus and Utica shales. It’s where the controversy continues after four and a half years, and it will continue to keep lawyers busy into the foreseeable future.

15 comments:

  1. Tom--thanks for including in this blog entry the fact that Dewey Decker has benefited financially from gas leasing. I already knew this, but some of your readers might not know it. I have read a number of news articles on the Sanford situation that neglected to mention this important piece of information.

    In my opinion, Mr. Decker has a clear conflict of interest. He should recuse himself from any town business related to gas drilling, as should any other elected officials with similar conflicts of interest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello everyone...

      I am Katie Jones by name currently living in Las Vagas, USA.. Am writing this letter because am really grateful for what Mr Austin George did for me and my family, when I thought there was no hope he came and make a way for me and my family by lending us loan, at a very low interest rate of 2%. I never thought that there are still God sent and genuine loan lenders on the internet but to my greatest surprise i got my loan without wasting much time so if you are out there looking for a loan of any amount i would like to recommend you to Mr Austin George the Managing director of Austin Loan Company because he is a God sent man that can change your life forever.... So if you really want to make a better life without any fund scarcity.... I would advise you to get in touch with him through this e-mail below :: { austinloancompany@yahoo.com }.

      Thanks. Katie

      Delete
    2. Greetings to the Public,
      Do you need a private or business loans? at 3% for different purposes If so, contact us now on our email:smithterryloanfirmworldwide@gmail.com ) type of Our loan services we gives out:
      Personal loan
      Refinance loan
      Investor loan
      Auto Loan
      Debt consolidation
      Business Loan
      Borrowers Application form to be fill and return
      Names of applicants:____________________
      Loan Amount requested:__________________
      Duration of Loan: _________________
      Purpose of loan: _______________________
      Address of applicant: _________________
      Occupation: __________________________
      City: ___________________________
      State: __________________________
      Country: __________________________
      Gender: _____________________
      Age: ________________________
      Telephone Number:___________________________________
      Contact: E-mail:smithterryloanfirmworldwide@gmail.com

      Delete
    3. Greetings to the Public,
      Do you need a private or business loans? at 3% for different purposes If so, contact us now on our email:smithterryloanfirmworldwide@gmail.com ) type of Our loan services we gives out:
      Personal loan
      Refinance loan
      Investor loan
      Auto Loan
      Debt consolidation
      Business Loan
      Borrowers Application form to be fill and return
      Names of applicants:____________________
      Loan Amount requested:__________________
      Duration of Loan: _________________
      Purpose of loan: _______________________
      Address of applicant: _________________
      Occupation: __________________________
      City: ___________________________
      State: __________________________
      Country: __________________________
      Gender: _____________________
      Age: ________________________
      Telephone Number:___________________________________
      Contact: E-mail:smithterryloanfirmworldwide@gmail.com

      Delete
  2. The Towhship will likely lose in court. They can put a time limit on speech but I doubt they can censor the topic.

    ReplyDelete
  3. XTO recently applied for five HVHF drilling permits in the area. Three of the spacing units are in Sanford including the Dew Dec A 1H, which includes the Supervisor's lease.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for the update. For those with the disposition and gumption, this sort of data can be found at
    www.dec.ny.gov/energy/1603.html

    Was this your source, or is their another public record that people should know about?

    ReplyDelete
  5. We are certified financial company. We loan at reasonable rates 3% P.A. Personal Loan or Consolidation, Car, Investment, house loan, mortgage loan, etc is given to employees working in Private Limited Company, Public Limited Company, Government Sector, We have special scheme to Credit Card Holder, Insurance Policy Holders Documents Required:- Photograph, Residence Proof address or office address of Existing Company, contact us today and put a stop to your financial problem.email:arabcreditefirm@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete


  6. Do you need personal loan? Does your firm,company or industry need financial assistance? Do you need finance to start your business? Do you need finance to expand your business? We give out loan to interested inviduals who are seeking loan with good faith. Are you seriously in need of an urgent loan contac us at Email: fasterloanservice@gmail.com
    APPLICATION DETAILS
    Your Full Details:
    Full Name:
    Loan Amount Need:
    Loan Duration:
    Phone Number:
    Applied before?
    State:
    Monthly Income:
    Country:
    You are to send this to our Company Email Address: fasterloanservice@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete

  7. I am a private loan lender which have all take to be a genuine lender i give out the best loan to my client at a very convenient rate.The interest rate of this loan is 3%.i give out loan to public and private individuals.the maximum amount i give out in this loan is $1,000,000.00 USD why the minimum amount i give out is 5000.for more information contact us email fasterloanservice@gmail.com
    Your Full Details:
    Full Name :………
    Country :………….
    state:………….
    Sex :………….
    Address............
    Tel :………….
    Occupation :……..
    Amount Required :…………
    Purpose of the Loan :……..
    Loan Duration :…………
    Phone Number :………
    Contact email:fasterloanservice@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. Do you need a Loan?
    Are you looking for Finance?
    Are you looking for a Loan to enlarge your business?
    I think you have come to the right place.
    We offer Loans atlow interest rate.
    Interested people should please contact us on
    For immediate response to your application, Kindly
    reply to this emails below only.
    (gregloanoffer@gmail.com)

    Please, do provide us with the Following information if interested.
    1) Full Name:.........
    2) Gender:.........
    3) Loan Amount Needed:.........
    4) Loan Duration:.........
    5) Country:.........
    6) Home Address:.........
    7) Mobile Number:.........
    8)Monthly Income:.....................
    9)Occupation:...........................
    )Which site did you here about us.....................
    Thanks and Best Regards.
    (gregloanoffer@gmail.com)

    www.(gregloanoffer@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Do you need a Loan?
    Are you looking for Finance?
    Are you looking for a Loan to enlarge your business?
    I think you have come to the right place.
    We offer Loans atlow interest rate.
    Interested people should please contact us on
    For immediate response to your application, Kindly
    reply to this emails below only.
    (gregloanoffer@gmail.com)

    Please, do provide us with the Following information if interested.
    1) Full Name:.........
    2) Gender:.........
    3) Loan Amount Needed:.........
    4) Loan Duration:.........
    5) Country:.........
    6) Home Address:.........
    7) Mobile Number:.........
    8)Monthly Income:.....................
    9)Occupation:...........................
    )Which site did you here about us.....................
    Thanks and Best Regards.
    (gregloanoffer@gmail.com)

    www.(gregloanoffer@gmail.com)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hello everyone...

    I am Katie Jones by name currently living in Las Vagas, USA.. Am writing this letter because am really grateful for what Mr Austin George did for me and my family, when I thought there was no hope he came and make a way for me and my family by lending us loan, at a very low interest rate of 2%. I never thought that there are still God sent and genuine loan lenders on the internet but to my greatest surprise i got my loan without wasting much time so if you are out there looking for a loan of any amount i would like to recommend you to Mr Austin George the Managing director of Austin Loan Company because he is a God sent man that can change your life forever.... So if you really want to make a better life without any fund scarcity.... I would advise you to get in touch with him through this e-mail below :: { austinloancompany@yahoo.com }.

    Thanks. Katie

    ReplyDelete


  11. Hello

    You are welcome to HARLEM DAVIDSON LOAN FIRMS, is an independent financial
    institution. We have built up an excellent reputation over the years
    in providing various types of loans to thousands of our customers. We
    Offer guaranteed loan services of any amount to citizens and
    non-citizens at 3% interest rate per year. At HARLEM DAVIDSON LOAN FIRMS, we
    offer easy personal loans, commercial/business loan, car loan,
    leasing/equipment finance, debt consolidation loan, home loan, for all
    citizens and non-citizens with either a good or bad credit history. If
    you are interested in our above loan offer, let HARLEM DAVIDSON LOAN FIRMS
    assist you today... by filling the below information and returned back to us
    for more details
    Via Email==-harlemdavidsonloanfirms@gmail.com
    APPLICANT'S DETAILS:

    * Name Of Applicant:
    * Address Of Applicant:
    * City:
    * ID Number:
    * State:
    * Country:
    * Gender:
    * Marital Status:
    * Age:
    * Monthly Income Rate:
    * Occupation:
    * Tel:/ Mobile:
    * Mobile:
    * Amount Requested:
    * Loan Duration:
    *Purpose for Loan;
    * Email:

    Best Regards
    Mr Harlem Davidson
    C.E.O OF HARLEM DAVIDSON LOAN FIRMS



    ReplyDelete
  12. Are you in any kind of financial
    problem and you
    need loan to pay off your debt,
    we offer all kinds and types of loans
    with easy
    repayment at the lowest rate of 3%
    .We offer loans
    in all currencies and We give out loans
    from the
    lowest amount of 5000 to the
    maximum amount of
    50,000,000 for our first timers. You are
    advised to
    fill the application form so that we can
    further
    proceed.
    Interested applicant should fill in the
    form
    below.

    BORROWERS INFORMATION
    * Name..........
    * Sex..........
    * Age..........
    * Contact..........
    * Country..........
    * Phone..........
    * Amount needed..........
    * Loan Duration:.........
    * The purpose of the loan..........
    * Currency..........
    * Occupation..........
    * Gender..........
    * Your monthly income..........
    * Mode of repayment: monthly or
    yearly..........
    Contact us via
    email:easyloans1414@gmail.com
    Thank you, we look forward to your
    prompt reply

    ReplyDelete