Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts

Sunday, August 11, 2013

Records add context to EPA’s aborted Dimock mission Letter from federal hazmat chief shows focus on Cabot

EPA officials begin investigation in Dimock in January 2012
PHOTO BY JAMES PITARRESI
More records are coming to light that show the EPA ended its investigation last year into the impact on fracking on Dimock water wells in the face of political pressure.

After finding arsenic, barium, manganese, chromium, and methane in wells at levels “that could propose a health concern” the agency declared no follow up was required because residents of affected homes had been notified and polluted wells were taken off line or equipped with filters. The contamination -- in roughly 8 percent of 61 wells tested -- was from naturally occurring compounds that are also used in or associated with drilling operations, which can exacerbate existing problems or introduce new ones.

The issue – one of national policy (or not) -- is recently getting the attention it deserves. Last month Neela Barnerjee of the LA Times reported that an internal EPA power point presentation showed that agency staff warned that methane pollution in Dimock was a likely result of shale gas operations that can cause long-term damage to aquifers. On this blog, I have reported that the EPA quietly turned the results of its investigation over to a sister agency called the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, where the outcome faces an uncertain fate. The ATSDR lacks the enforcement muscle of the EPA, has a relatively small budget and staff, and is notoriously slow.

But there’s more to it, and much of the back-story can be found in a series of internal correspondence and documentation uncovered through a freedom of information request by Laura Legere, of the Scranton Times Union. These memos and others now available on line show EPA officials were urgently concerned about pollution documented in Cabot’s own testing of the water, as well as files kept by Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection. This was the starting point of the EPA investigation, which intended to “characterize” conditions that were causing disconcerting test results.

A memo dated Dec. 7. 2011 (date corrected from original post) from Jon Capacasa, director of the EPA’s Water Protection Division, captures the urgency of the EPA’s request to the ATSDR to evaluate the health risk of chemicals already documented by Cabot and the DEP.

We believe that the private wells in and around the Dimock area have been negatively impacted by the Cabot natural gas drilling process as evidenced by the presence of methane, butane, propane, ethane, ethene, etc., related gas compounds and also the presence of high concentrations of secondary contaminants like aluminum, iron, manganese, etc. 
We have recently received additional data identifying additional organic chemicals Butyl benzyl phthalate, Triethylene Glycol and 2 Methoxyethanol among others....
This is an urgent matter to the Agency so completion of your review within the next two months is requested.

While EPA staff found the matter urgent, they also noted that test results were not produced by the agency itself. To get their own data, staffers were mindful about overstepping the agency’s jurisdictional boundaries, which are limited due to fracking industry’s exemptions from the Safe Drinking Water Act and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act. In justifying the Dimock investigation, the EPA recognized the issue to be “nationally significant and precedent setting” under the federal Superfund law, as detailed in this Jan. 19, 2012 scoping memo from site coordinater Richard Fetzer.

EPA routinely acts under CERCLA [superfund] to protect public health first while it acts to further define contamination. …
Because the action appears to be nationally significant and/or precedent-setting, the Region will continue to coordinate closely with Headquarters. EPA also will maintain coordination and communications with the PADEP. In taking this action, EPA is aware of and has considered the potential applicability of the natural gas exclusion under CERCLA, the Bensten Amendment under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) and the exclusion to the definition of the “underground injection” under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA). EPA has concluded that this action is appropriate under CERCLA at this time.

The original scope of work, which was later dropped, included determining the source of pollution. In a letter dated Jan. 6, 2012 notifying Cabot attorney Kevin Cunningham of the investigation and a request for records, EPA’s hazardous cleanup director Ronald Borsellino stated the agency was “investigating the source, extent and nature of a release or threatened release of hazardous substances” related to the company’s operations.

Fetzer’s Jan. 29 internal memo sumed it up this way:

What is clear is that this data strongly suggests that hazardous substances have been released and are present in some home well at levels that may present a public health concern. 
Current data does show arsenic and manganese at higher levels than may be typically found in post drilling samples.  Since arsenic and manganese are naturally occurring substances, EPA’s assessment will include comparison of background concentrations present. 

All this qualification, of course, was partly the product of due diligence by the EPA to make its investigation withstand the expected pushback from the state and the industry and to make a case for involvement under Superfund.

States generally are protective of their jurisdiction over shale gas, and this is a critical piece of context. The EPA was conducting a similar investigation in Pavillion, Wyoming, where it found evidence that shale gas development polluted water wells of homes on the Wind River Reservation. Predictably, the agency faced a hostile reception by Wyoming Gov. Matt Mead, a shale gas proponent who characterized the federal action as an example of regulatory overreach. (The EPA recently aborted its plans for a peer reviewed study of its work in Pavillion and turned the investigation over to the state.) The EPA faced a similar reaction from Pennsylvania state officials.

On Jan 5, 2012, (then) Pennsylvania DEP director Michael Krancer wrote to EPA Regional Administrator Shawn Gravin, citing Wyoming Governor Mead’s criticism of the EPA’s investigation in Pavillion. In Krancer’s words, that criticism involved:

the technical, scientific and cooperation shortcomings of EPA’s activities with respect to that state regarding Pavilion and there is no need here to catalogue those in his [Mead's] letter. Suffice it to say that we hope the EPA’s efforts here not be marked by the same rush to conclusions and other deficiencies here as it was and continues to be in respect to the Pavilion matter. . I ask that your efforts be guided by sound science and law rather than emotion and publicity.

Krancer copied a group of Pennsylvania legislators on his letter.

All this correspondence shows how the EPA was in a defensive position from the get go, even though its tests later affirmed a persistent problem with arsenic and methane in some wells. In one well, EPA tests found arsenic at nine times the federal safety standards, prompting the agency to call for an alternative source of water  because the levels posed “significant threat to the residents health,” according to an internal memo from Dennis Carney of EPA’s region 3 to his colleagues. (The name of the well's owner was redacted in the file.)

But there is still a missing piece: Why did the agency suddenly drop its investigation without accounting for the source of pollution in Dimock or characterizing the broader groundwater conditions, as it set out to do? The answer has something to do with jurisdictional limits due to the exemptions from federal law. But an overriding element involves Obama’s campaign platform for a second term, when the president was publically and enthusiastically pitching the merits of shale gas and portraying himself as an industry ally. As the campaign heated up in 2012, the EPA investigation could have backfired if held up in the hands of his opponents as evidence that the president is a regulatory zealot. In fact, Cabot Oil & Gas president Dan Dinges wasted no time exploiting this angle in an open letter -- shortly after the company was put on notice by the EPA – which was promptly featured in a report by Mark Drajem for Bloomberg:

EPA’s actions in Dimock appear to undercut the president’s stated commitment to this important resource,” Chief Executive Officer Dan Dinges wrote today in a letter to EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson. “EPA’s approach has caused confusion that undermines important policy goals of the United States to ensure safe, reliable, secure and clean energy sources from domestic natural gas.
The EPA said Jan. 19 that it would deliver water to four families in Dimock, where residents say their water has been contaminated during hydraulic fracturing by Cabot. The EPA will also test water at 60 homes to assess whether any residents are being exposed to hazardous substances, the agency said.
Dinges, who also is Cabot’s chairman, said today that the company provided more than 10,000 pages of data to the EPA and there is “no credible evidence” that the water needs further analysis by the federal agency. 
“It appears as though the EPA’s decision is politically motivated and not based on a legitimate desire to address environmental concerns,” the company said in a statement issued with Dinges’s letter.

Dinges was clearly hitting effective buttons. In the world we live in, politics in addition to science is an element of policy making. And here is an example where the direction of science was driven by political forces and interpretations.


Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Actions, not words provide insight into NY’s fracking future 3 signs the state will not permit shale gas anytime soon


Early last summer, Governor Andrew Cuomo proposed to allow fracking on a test basis in certain areas along the state’s border with Pennsylvania over a prime area of the Marcellus Shale.  A month later, Cuomo suggested that the state’s policy review on the issue would be completed by Labor Day, or shortly after.

We have since learned that information from Cuomo and his staff about fracking has been consistent only in that it has been reliably contradictory, vague, and carefully crafted to appear neutral amid a firestorm of controversy and partisanship that have come to define New York’s fracking dilemma.   

Recent examples:

On Feb. 4, Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner Joe Martens entered a legislative hearing room in the capitol where protesters outnumbered lawmakers and staff by more than three to one. Pressed by lawmakers, Martens testified that the final piece of the state’s policy review for gas permitting would be released by the Department of Health within “a few weeks.” That piece consists of a DOH review of whether the DEC’s plan to oversee the industry– outlined in a document called the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (SGEIS) -- would sufficiently protect public health. Oddly, the administration has not released any scoping document, time frame, or explanation of the DOH review, and Martens told lawmakers DOH Commissioner Nirav Shah had not shared any specifics about its status with the DEC.

On Feb. 12, the DEC released a two-page memo from DOH Commissioner Shah to Martens explaining that the DOH review and recommendations would be completed “within a few weeks.”  Shah advised that, in the meantime, the DOH staff was reviewing three studies evaluating the impact of fracking on public health elsewhere. They include a federal EPA evaluation of risks to groundwater, and two studies evaluating public health indicators near shale gas development in Pennsylvania, including one by Geisinger Health Systems that will evaluate hundreds of thousands of records of patients living in shale gas regions. None of the studies will be completed this year, and Shah did not explain how DOH staff might be able to glean useful information from them in a few weeks. The tone of his letter suggested an indefinite delay.

The time to ensure the impacts on public health are properly considered is before a state permits drilling. Other states began serious health reviews only after proceeding with widespread HVHF.
In my view, that is not the right approach for New York to take if we are serious that public health is the paramount question in making the HVHF decision. And as Health Commissioner, protecting the public health is my primary job.

Since the release of the memo, Martens, Shah, and Cuomo have downplayed the notion that the review could hinder permitting for very long. The day after the memo was released, Martens said the state could still move forward with permitting shale wells, even though it missed a key deadline to adopt regulations. At a March 11 cabinet meeting, Shah said that the final DOH analysis would be done “in the next few weeks,” and in the next sentence declared the administration has “no time table” to complete it’s work, and that the science under evaluation “was a moving target.” At the same meeting, in response to a query from Gannett’s Albany correspondent Jon Campbell, Cuomo characterized the follow-up work by the DOH as possibly irrelevant. “We never said you had to wait for one of those studies or all three of those studies to finish,” he explained. “Just that they would be looked at during the pendency of the Department of Health Review.”

Campbell followed up with this logical question: If you don’t have results from those studies, what value are they to the Department of Health’s review?

Cuomo shrugged. “I don’t know,” he said. “Call them up. Look at them. Talk to them and find out. Maybe they are totally useless. In which case they’re useless. Maybe they have some information that is instructive to you. In which case you use the information.”

I took the governor’s suggestion. I learned that the DOH staff completed its meeting with administrators of the studies weeks ago, but I could find out nothing regarding what exactly health officials were looking at or how it would be factored into the SGEIS. Amanda O'Rourke, a spokeswoman for Geisinger, confirmed that DOH officials met with members of the Geisinger research team in late February, but added “we are not granting interviews on this topic at this time.” Asked why, she replied:  “I simply prefer not to discuss the meeting.”

This tells us only that the Cuomo administration, at the expense of transparency, has designed it’s fracking modus operandi to neutralize offensives from lobbyists and grass roots activists that inevitably accompany every small sign and huge expectation that the administration is leaning one way or the other. Rather than hanging on words, those trying to predict when and if shale gas wells will be sunk in New York are better off looking at more tangible signs within the administration, including these:

1) No budget for regulatory staff. DEC administrators have said the agency will need at least 140 new staff members to regulate the shale gas industry in New York. The governor’s budget, now under negotiation with legislators, contains no money to add staff for shale gas permitting or inspection. Moreover, an advisory panel of lawmakers and representatives from the industry and environmental groups tasked with looking at revenue sources for this function has not met in the past two years, and there are no signs of it being reconvened.

2) Recent departures suggest a critical disconnect. Two administrators key to drilling policy have inexplicably resigned in recent weeks. The most high profile departure was that of Robert Hallman, Cuomo’s deputy secretary for energy and environment who is on record as advocating shale gas development as an important bridge to cleaner energy fuel sources. Perhaps more relevant, however, is the resignation of Deputy Commissioner and General Counsel Steve Russo, who was instrumental in overseeing the development of the SGEIS under Cuomo. Given that both pro and anti-fracking groups have threatened to challenge the legal soundness of the state’s policy, it seems unlikely that Cuomo would proceed without a successor to Russo who is up to speed on the legal complexity of issues that have been evolving since 2008.

3) Everything remains on hold, as deadlines pass. The most current reason for the delay – that the DOH staff is looking at other studies – is ill defined and, as Cuomo suggested, possibly irrelevant. Further, the “few weeks” timetable for that work has long passed. I have heard from multiple sources that the work is in fact done, and there are larger forces at work.  As much as those close to the fracking debate would like to see the decision made in a political vacuum, it seldom if ever works that way. The fracking decision, which is also pending legislation, is one of many chips on the big table on which things get done in Albany. Gun Control (recently passed but still relevant), Minimum Wage, Casino designations, Stop and Frisk, and myriad budget issues.

For worse or better, Cuomo has decided that fracking, for now, is one of those issues that remains on the table. The glut of gas coming on the market in Pennsylvania has made this the path of least resistance for him, as it has substantially eased the demand for New York’s share of the resource while lowering prices. Tension between both camps of the fracking debate – and poles suggesting a split in the broader public (recently nudging slightly toward anti-frackers) – suggest the status quo is less damaging to Cuomo than the sequence of events that would come with a clear commitment for or against fracking. 

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Reading the regs: missing pieces confound NY gas policy Some happier than others with signals from Albany

With a keystone policy document still under wraps, stakeholders are having a hard time assessing merits and drawbacks of New York’s fracking regulations issued in draft form last week.

The missing piece is a compilation of environmental and health considerations that will be a primary tool for issuing permits under Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s administration. Those considerations are the focus of a 1,500-plus page document called the Generic Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SGEIS), which has been a work in progress since 2008. The document addresses health and environmental impacts of developing the Marcellus and Utica shale reserves as determined by the Department of Environmental Conservation and the Department of Health, and offers a plan to manage them. In response to concerns by activist late last year, the DEC commissioned an independent panel of health experts to review the DEC’s work in the SGEIS. With that review pending, the Cuomo administration has said it is still leaving the door open to shelve the entire process.

After two drafts, the final SGEIS is expected to be made public within a three month deadline the state now faces to finalize its regulatory package. The deadline to get rules in place, originally Nov. 29, was extended after the DEC issued a draft of the regulations last week, minus the pivotal environmental and health reviews in the SGEIS. In the meantime, as fracking critics continue to pore over the draft regulations issued last week, they are finding little to like. Industry proponents, on the other hand, see encouraging signs.

Anti-frackers lodged complaints regarding form, content and timing of the draft regulations, which they see as a reflection of haphazardness common to the entire process. A collection of elected officials, public health advocates, and environmental activists gathered in Albany Monday to call for transparency in developing policy. In particular, the group is concerned over the lack of explanation regarding how the state is assessing health risks. Joined by assemblywoman Barbara Lifton, Binghamton Mayor Matt Ryan, and ecologist and anti-fracking activist Sandra Steingraber, they called on Gov. Andrew Cuomo to make public the scope of the health review and schedule a public comment period and hearing to air testimony specifically dealing with health-related concerns.

In talking with representatives of some of the agencies in a position to legally challenge the DEC’s regulatory approach, I found this salient charge: The process is characterized by confusion, lack of transparency, and inaccessibility, and critics cite as a prime example the release of the regulations before the health and environmental assessment. While fracking opponents gathered for the Albany press conference, Deborah Goldberg, an attorney for EarthJustice, studied the draft regulations in her office in New York City. (Note Goldberg's first name has been corrected from the original version of this post.) She found problems from the start with organizational flaws that make the technically dense documents inscrutable. Because changes are not redlined, reviewers have to flip back and forth between existing regulations developed decades ago for conventional gas development, early drafts of proposed amendments for shale gas, and the current documents. Moreover, the changes could not be considered in context of the broader health and environmental reviews that remain unfinished. This has made the process unnecessarily cumbersome for professional and citizen reviewers who face a 30-day deadline to comment.

“It’s extremely unhelpful to issue these to the public with no references or context and with a compressed public comment period over the holidays,” Goldberg said. “You would think you would make this as easy as possible, but they’re asking us to critique the regs without key components made public, and rushing the entire process.”

The regulations deal with the how of shale gas development, from spacing units to containment measures to setbacks. They inform, for example, that pads and discharges are not allowed within 500 feet of a primary aquifer or within 2000 feet of primary municipal water supplies. But they don’t address the qualitative issues – purportedly addressed in the SGEIS -- that have been at the center of the fracking debate. What will the cumulative impacts be? What rights do local governments have? How can this affect public health” And who will bare the cost of enforcement?

Some representatives of environmental agencies told me they were disappointed that the new regs apparently did little to sanction environmental safeguards expressed by DEC staff members during meetings earlier this year. The safeguards include green completion -- a process to minimize pressurized releases of methane and other pollution by banning development of wells before infrastructure is in place to capture, contain and transport gas; and wells to monitor ground water conditions around gas operations. It was unclear whether these types of safeguards would be detailed in the SGEIS and stipulated under permitting conditions.

“It’s bizarre that we are being asked to comment on something without seeing the compendium of its meaning,” said Roger Downs, executive director of the Atlantic Chapter of the Sierra Club.

Not everybody was unhappy about the regs, however. Drilling proponents were encouraged that the DEC met the deadline to allow the process to move forward rather than expire. Gas drilling proponents have pointed to the four-and-a-half year review process, with multiple comment periods and hearings reflected in previous drafts of the SGEIS, as a sufficient effort to publically air concerns and develop policy. Proponents feel that, by meeting the deadline last week, the agency continues a good faith effort to allow the review to proceed.

“They kept the regulations alive, which was a surprise,” said Tom West, an industry lawyer. “It’s a light at the end of the tunnel. It’s good to see we are nearing the end.” West added that drilling proponents had reservations of a different sort. Specifically, he found rules that ban drilling in watersheds that feed New York City, Syracuse and other major aquifers to be too restrictive. “It raises questions about access to the resource,” he said.

If regulations are completed in three months, West estimated that it may take a half a year or more after that for permits to work their way through the new regulatory system.

Assuming the other pieces fall in place before the 90-day extension for the draft regs expires, and assuming the governor then gives a green light to permitting, there are several wild cards that cannot be accounted for, including possible legislative initiatives and legal challenges that could still delay or derail the process.

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Cuomo buys more time for New York fracking decision DEC: draft regs do not signal commitment to shale gas

It’s been another frenzied week on the fracking front in Albany – with much sound and fury signifying nothing.

Or not?

Another deadline came and went amid confusion and contention about the timing and protocol of issuing draft regulations for shale gas development in New York. To clear things up, Governor Andrew Cuomo’s administration issued a statement Friday saying everything is still up in the air.

We learned, after the administration filed draft regs to avoid a deadline that would have derailed the epic policy process, that the Governor is still undecided. The draft regulations over which officials at state Department of Environmental Conservation have toiled for the past year are not a reflection of the governor’s intentions to embrace or reject shale gas.

“If DEC decides that hydraulic fracturing cannot be safely done in New York, these regulations will not have any practical effect and the process will not go forward,” read the statement from DEC spokeswoman Emily DeSantis. “If DEC decides that the process can be done safely, these regulations would be adjusted in accordance with the health and safety requirements and issues addressed in the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement.”

The statement came two days after the administration kept alive the prospect of shale gas development by quietly issuing the pending regulations – still a work in progress -- to meet a Nov. 29th administrative deadline. Failure to meet the deadline would mean the rulemaking process would expire. That would be a relief to fracking opponents, because it would send the administration back to the drawing board and re-open the process to the contentious public hearings that have built momentum for a well organized and motivated anti-fracking movement. The movement has gone nationwide, and New York occupies center stage. For that same reason, missing the deadline would have been a blow to fracking proponents – including groups of landowners eager to lease their land, backed by conservative business interests and the industry’s advertising and lobbying muscle. (Proponents see high volume hydraulic fracturing – a process to extract natural gas from bedrock by injecting large volumes of pressured chemical solution -- as vital to economic development and energy independence. Opponents see it as environmental ruin and building dependence on fossil fuels.)

Nobody knew right up to and following the final hour of the deadline what course Cuomo’s DEC would take, and when the hour came and went, not everybody was even sure whether the state had filed the regs because no official notice was given. While there was no attempt by the governor’s office to defuse the matter, I know from sources close to this that their was a frenzied push by DEC staff to meet the deadline even as representatives from influential environmental groups made last ditch calls to urge them to hold off, at least until the agency could receive analysis of a panel of independent health experts commissioned to review DEC’s policy.

So why didn’t the DEC issue a statement to clear things up in advance of all this rather than switch to damage control amid protest that followed?

An obvious read of the situation is that meeting the deadline represents a step toward rather than a step away from shale gas development. Why would the agency be sweating the details over thousands pages of dense policy – flawed in the eyes of some and sound in the eyes of others and certain to meet legal challenges from many angles -- if officials were ready to shelve the entire regulatory project that has been under fire for more than four years?

The answer is that Cuomo himself -- two years away from a gubernatorial election and/or possibly four years away from a presidential bid -- is buying as much time as he can while attempting to manage the political forces at work that will influence his career and shale gas development in particular. Regardless of the outcome, he will have to answer two critical political constituencies. Well-healed and internationally renown environmental groups such as the National Resources Defense Council (among others) and Big Oil and the business lobby. Both of these institutional forces are backed by impassioned grass roots bases. Adding to the complications: Cuomo cannot yet gauge Legislative positions, as control of the Senate remains undecided.

The action of the last week tells us, if anything, that Cuomo is taking the fracking conundrum day-by-day if not hour-by-hour. The decision to meet the deadline by issuing a draft of the regs sends a signal to industry supporters that the administration is moving forward in good faith to get policy in place that would allow shale gas development. The statement that came retroactively to explain the decision was clearly intended to calm an uprising with the anti-fracking movement by suggesting that the administration has not passed the point of no return.

Here is the entire statement from the DEC:

The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation DEC has filed a Notice of Continuation with the Department of State to extend the rulemaking process by 90 days in order to give New York State Commissioner of Health, Dr. Nirav Shah, time to complete his review of the draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement. This extension is necessary, in part, because Commissioner Martens requested and Dr. Shah agreed to provide an additional review, in consultation with outside experts, of whether DEC has adequately addressed potential impacts to public health. This filing with the Department of State merely extends the rulemaking period to enable Dr. Shah to complete his review and DEC time to take into account the results of Dr. Shah’s review and continue to consider the potential impacts of high-volume hydraulic fracturing.

In order to receive the needed extension, DEC was required by law to refile the draft regulations along with responses to public comments received during the public comment period, and preliminary revisions, responsive to those comments. The refiled rule does not reflect current DEC policy with respect to whether or not hydraulic fracturing can be done safely in New York. That determination will be based on the findings of the environmental impact statement and Dr. Shah’s public health review of that document.

DEC will not take any final action or make any decision regarding hydraulic fracturing until after Dr. Shah’s health review is completed and DEC, through the environmental impact statement, is satisfied that this activity can be done safely in New York State.

If DEC decides that hydraulic fracturing cannot be safely done in New York, these regulations will not have any practical effect and the process will not go forward. If DEC decides that the process can be done safely, these regulations would be adjusted in accordance with the health and safety requirements and issues addressed in the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement.

Thursday, September 27, 2012

November 29 deadline looms for final NY fracking policy Cuomo administration may file for 90-day extension

While Governor Andrew Cuomo refuses to say when or whether New York will begin permitting shale gas wells, the answer lies in a little-known fact: his administration faces a Nov. 29 legal deadline to finalize a decision.

An obscure provision of a technically-dense law provides the most concrete clues about when the public can expect Shale Gas policy in New York. The law is called the State Administrative Procedures Act (SAPA). Several lawyers have called my attention to Section 202, which spells out how administrative agencies are required to go about rulemaking. Specifically, the provision states that regulations have to be finalized one year from the last public hearing on the issue under review unless an extension is filed.

It’s a fact that has gained little attention beyond the circle of lawyers who have been following the issue closely as they develop strategy in support or against fracking in New York.

Helen Slottje, an attorney with the Community Environmental Defense Council, told me she is expecting the policy to be released on or about Nov. 29. This is precisely one year from the date of the last public hearing on the state’s review of fracking policy and, in Slottje’s view, a politically opportune time to release a controversial policy decision, because it’s “a time when most people have a ton of other things to do, the elections are over, and the legislature is not in session.”

The DEC also has the option of filing for a 90-day extension. That would make the deadline March 1, or thereabouts.

The DEC began its formal review of shale gas policy under the David Paterson administration in summer of 2008 through a document called the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (or SGEIS). Originally, the SGEIS was a vehicle to update permitting guidelines for shale gas wells and an amendment to regulations dating to 1992 governing conventional well development. But Cuomo’s administration, wary of legal challenges to derail the shale gas industry’s advancement into New York, began a formal rulemaking process – folded into the environmental review -- to update regulations. Public hearings scheduled for the SGEIS also satisfied the requirements for the rulemaking process, thereby subjecting the entire policy package to the SAPA deadline. If the DEC misses the Nov. 29 deadline without filing an extension, the agency could face a do-over of the review --- including the public hearings that have produced more than 80,000 public comments and critiques that have already delayed the process for years.

The scope of the review was originally environmental, but health advocates have also gotten involved by posing questions about the short and long-term impact on public health from all aspects of shale gas development – not just fracking. Fear of law suits is thematic in the agency’s response. Last week, DEC Commissioner Joseph Martens announced that, because of those questions, the policy proposal will now be evaluated by the Health Department, which will assemble an independent panel, to “ensure the strongest possible legal position for the Department given the near certainty of litigation, whether the Department permits hydrofracking or not.”

Several lawyers questioned whether the state can complete the health review with due diligence before the Nov. 29 deadline.

“They have, of course, been clear that they won’t issue the final regulations until the health review is complete,” said Kate Sinding, a senior attorney for the National Resources Defense Council – one of the agencies that pushed for the health review. “Whether they try to shoehorn that in between now and November 29th … or opt to extend the deadline by 90 days, which they can legally do, we don’t know.” She doubted the agency could make the Nov. 29th deadline while acting in good faith to complete the health review. “It seems unlikely that they could do what needs to be done to accomplish the objectives of a real Health Impact Assessment in such an abbreviated timeframe.”

Tom West, a lawyer and lobbyist who represents the industry, said he didn’t expect the review to be complete before the first of the year. In that case, West said the agency “can let it (the rulemaking application) lapse, republish with a 30 day public comment period that gets them a 90 day extension, or re-propose the rulemaking if there have been substantive changes, which effectively starts the process over.”

Chris Denton, a lease attorney in Elmira, predicted the policy review was drawing to a close after more than four years. Denton said he believes the Cuomo administration has quietly factored the Nov. 29 deadline into its overall strategy. “Cuomo’s not going to miss this deadline,” Denton said. “It sends the wrong message.”

While the pending policy package is a central component to a tactical fight to delay or expedite shale gas development in New York, there are other factors. The price of gas has fallen with a market glut. With that, political pressure has eased along with the pace of aggressive prospecting, exploration, and lucrative lease offers that marked the 2008 land rush.

Cuomo also faces the uncertainty of whether Democrats, who have generally opposed a rush to begin permitting gas wells in favor of more study, will control the Legislature after elections, or whether it will remain split. The anti-fracking movement has been keeping pressure high by effectively challenging the credibility of the DEC, and specifically the agency’s claim that it has a spotless record regulating the gas industry. This week, Walter Hang brought to light more records of spills and abandonment – ample evidence, he says, that the DEC is ill-equipped to handle conventional shale gas development, much less the more intense and wide-spread operations of a shale gas play and the legacy it may leave the next generation.

As president of a data base firm called Toxic Targeting and formerly a community organizer with New York Public Interest Research Group, Hang is a long-time government watchdog and industry antagonist. The story with his relationship with the DEC is told in Under the Surface, and this week’s developments are a continuation of that battle. Hang’s company tracks corporate pollution through government records, and this week he released annual reports and other information that show 4,800 known abandoned wells, and a like number yet to be discovered in woods, backyards, playgrounds and under buildings. Unplugged or improperly plugged wells can cause explosions and risks to water supplies by providing a pathway for methane to move into enclosed spaces and for hydrocarbons and other toxic pollutants to migrate into the water table.

The problem is obscured by lack of reporting requirements and enforcement. When claims of water contamination are reported, the DEC Mineral Resources Division, the lead investigative agency, often leaves it up to the industry to settle with property owners who face a high burden of proof and experienced industry legal teams. Claims of liability from explosions face the same problem. Some of these cases were picked up by local health officials frustrated with the DEC’s denial of problems. As previously reported in this blog and in Under the Surface, William T. Boria, a water resources specialist at the Chautauqua County Health Department, tracked more than 140 complaints related to water pollution or gas migration associated with a boom in nearby conventional drilling operations (prior to shale gas development). In a 2004 memo summarizing the issue, he concluded “Those complaints that were recorded are probably just a fraction of the actual problems that occurred.” County health officials tabulated information on 53 of the cases from 1983 to 2008 on a spreadsheet, including methane migration, brine pollution, and at least one in which a home had to be evacuated after the water well exploded. “A representative I spoke with from the Division of Minerals [of the DEC] insists that the potential for drinking water contamination by oil and gas drilling is almost non-existent,” Boria wrote in his memo to a party whose name was redacted. “However, this department has investigated numerous complaints of potential contamination problems resulting from oil and gas drilling.” (Pennsylvania has similar problems. According to a briefing by the Department of Environmental Protection to Pennsylvania state’s Oil and Gas Technical Advisory Board, a group of state government–appointed industry representatives that advises the agency on technical and policy matters, methane migration from gas drilling, had “caused or contributed to” at least six explosions that killed four people and injured three others over the course of the decade preceding full-scale Marcellus development. The threat of explosions had forced 20 families from their homes, sometimes for months. At least 25 other families have had to deal with the shut-off of utility service or the installation of venting systems in their homes. At least 60 water wells -- including three municipal supplies-- had been contaminated.)

In addition to the orphan wells in New York, Hang most recently uncovered agency documentation that showed vegetation killed by leaking waste pits, brine leaking from rusted storage tanks, and crude oil contaminating residential wells and streams.

“Governor Cuomo can talk all he wants about good science,” Hang said. “This data shows that the DEC does not enforce the law.”

Questions persist whether the agency has the manpower to enforce regulations once they are drafted. In 2010, DEC Commissioner Peter Grannis was fired by Larry Schwartz, Paterson’s secretary (and now Cuomo’s secretary) after a memo by Grannis was leaked that suggested the DEC, decimated by cuts, would lack the ability to effectively regulate.